Surprise! Credit scores are calculated differently depending on the methodology used and the credit bureau compiling the report. Learn what the differences are and take control of your own financial responsibility.
By taking the time to understand how credit functions and how your credit score is calculated, you will not only gain invaluable information, but be able to take actions to improve your scores.
Through financial literacy, you will achieve more control over your financial security.
Are All Scores The Same?
No. Not necessarily.
Because of FICO scores’ majority role, most information available relates directly to FICO scores for simplicity and practicality. That being said, it is important to be aware that there is always a slight possibility one or more of your credit scores is not a FICO score.
Your credit report should list if the score is a FICO score or not. If it is not explicit, you can always contact the agency to find out.
Furthermore, because the credit bureaus each calculate scores differently, a FICO score from one agency may differ from the FICO score from another agency. In other words, there can even be different versions of FICO scores.
One note: VantageScores is an alternative to FICO scoring and has gained popularity recently. Like FICO scores, it uses analytics to create a composite image of borrowers’ financial responsibility and reliability.
How Many Different Credit Bureaus Are There?
For each of these three national credit bureaus, you have a separate FICO score.
While each of the bureaus compile essentially the same types of data, your FICO score could be different for each bureau.
What’s On A Credit Report?
- Identifying Information: Such as your name, current and previous addresses, SS#, dob and employment information
- Credit Accounts: Like credit cards, auto loans, mortgages, etc.
- Credit Inquiries: When someone requests information regarding your credit history, those requests appear in this section
- Public Records: Legal documents from state and county courts can be collected by credit reporting agencies. These documents can be records of bankruptcy, foreclosures, suits, liens, wage attachments, etc.
- Collections: If you have any overdue debt from collection agencies, that information is also included
How Is My Credit Score Calculated?
Broadly speaking, FICO Scores are a composite of:
- 35% Payment History
- 30% Amounts Owed
- 15% Length of Credit History
- 10% Types of Credit
- 10% New Credit
You can tell the importance by the weight of each category, so if you are trying to improve your FICO score, look at amounts owed and payment history to begin with. Keep in mind, however, that even the categories with lower percentages can be influential. So, don’t overlook these areas simply because they do not carry more weight.
Note what the FICO score ignores:
- Race, ethnicity, religion, national origin, sex, marital status
- Age
- Salary, occupation, position, employer, employment history
- Location
- Interest rate changes
- Family support obligations, including child support and alimony (however, missed child support does stay on your report; the obligation itself to pay is not documented unless you fail to pay on time)
- Certain credit inquiries: employer, administrative, pre-approval, promotional or self/consumer-initiated inquiries
In other words, your identifying information and anything not found on your credit report does not influence the score.
Credit Scores Can Be Different Between Bureaus?
It is important to remember that while credit scores from different bureaus can vary, they should be relatively close if all of your collected information is identical.
It can happen, however, that the information compiled by Equifax, TransUnion and Experian is not all the same.
Each bureau uses particular methodology to optimize the predictive value of your credit history. In other words, the formulas for calculating credit scores are in place to determine as accurately as possible how you will act and react financially in the future.
REMEMBER: Credit scores are a snapshot of your history used to paint your future financial portrait.
Why Wouldn’t Bureaus Have Identical Information On Me?
The most common reason would be that the collection processes are not the same.
Not all creditors/lenders are required to report. Because of this, your credit report may not reflect every line of credit you have.
For instance, some national department store/bank credit cards may not appear on your report – because it may not be required of that particular creditor, they may opt out of voluntary reporting.
If you find out that certain lines of credit are not on your report, you can always ask your creditors to report your accounts. They may not oblige, but it never hurts to ask. This can be especially helpful if you have been told by lenders that you have insufficient or no credit, but you do hold lines of credit; this can be an easy step to begin building that history.
Besides Different Information Collected By The Bureaus, Why Else Would My Scores Be Different?
- Timing: If your credit scores are not compiled at the same time, the data may have significantly changed – especially if you are just starting to build history and the length and breadth of your credit history is small.
- Names: Particularly relevant if you have had a surname change (through marriage or divorce, most commonly), but if you applied for a line of credit under a nickname or truncation of your legal name, that can cause fragmentation or incomplete files on the credit reporting agencies.
- Inaccurate/Incomplete Information: If addresses change or social security numbers are mis typed, information can also be divided and not compiled wholly.
Remember, your credit score is an indicator of your financial habits; it illustrates your level of responsibility and can be used to predict how you will handle finances in the future. When used as a tool to build your financial reputation, credit accounts can be have unparalleled benefits.
When used correctly, credit can be a saving grace and not a death sentence to your financial stability.
Educate yourself today and take control of your financial reputation.